3BR House Vacation Rental in Shelter Island, New York

Vacation Rentals

Updated on Aug 15, 2019

Peaceful Shelter Island Getaway-Directly Across From Preserved Land

Located in: Shelter Island
Enjoy a charming 3 bedroom on an expansive shy acre corner plot located directly across from Sylvester Manor Farm. The land across the street is a preserve and the adjacent lot is undeveloped which allows for plenty of relaxation and privacy. An 800 sqft (open plan) great room with two balconies and large windows is perfect for entertaining or lounging with a good book. The home also boasts a freshly renovated kitchen with new appliances. The rear balcony descends to a gravel patio area with a fire pit, dining area and charcoal BBQ grill. Owners are very reasonable, responsive, and pet friendly!

*2 bedrooms have their own AC unit. There is also another AC in the bedroom hallway which feeds the bedrooms . The upstairs has a large ceiling fan plus an ac unit. Often times the cross breeze from the screened in balconies and the fan is sufficient.

About the Area: Shelter Island is unique to Long Island's east end because it's only accessible by ferry. Upon arriving in S.I., you truly feel like you are in a different world with vacation mode fully setting in. You may be happy to hear that the island has been dubbed the "un Hamptons" by some because of its low key, relaxed and quiet atmosphere. Shelter Island is home to the 2,100 acre Mashomack Preserve which contains about 10 miles of coastline and represents 1/3 of the island. There you find breathtaking views of fields, creeks, and shoreline. If you are in the mood for an adventure, hop on the north ferry towards Greenport or the south ferry towards Sag Harbor and The Hamptons.

Additional notable amenities:

-Queen sized air mattress and cot available for additional guests

-Workstation with WIFI and a new printer/scanner

-New 55" smart TV plus basic cable

-Charcoal BBQ grill

-New Hammock

-AC in each bedroom

-12 cup coffee machine

-New washer/dryer

-Working fireplace

-Outdoor patio set

-Walking distance to mini golf

-Located close to marina & beaches.
Get the full listing »

More Vacation Rentals Near Shelter Island,

VRBO.com logo

Five Star 5000 sq ft Beautiful & Spacious Home Heated Pool

6 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

COPY LINK BELOW AND PASTE IN BROWSER FOR VIRTUAL TOUR http://tour.vht.com/433503005/idxs Copy link for video tour https://vimeo.com/352085936/48de5a8a47 The perfect vacation home in the heart of...

$ummer $pecial @ Bridgehampton's Best South Location

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Guests return repeatedly to BH3 (Big Happy Bridgehampton Beach House), a very special place in the ideal 'south-of-highway' location, equally as close to the stunning ocean beach as to the charming...

Private Waterfront, nature, kayak,swim, peace. Great all seasons getaway.

2 bedroom cottage in Shelter Island, NY

50' from the best fresh water swimming on Long Island WITH NO MOTOR BOATS. An incredible find. Country cottage at Southampton's back up fresh water reservoir. Treat yourself to the silky waters of our...

Spacious Montauk Beach House with Ocean View - Rental Registry Number 18-138

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

A beautiful and spacious Montauk beach house with a terrific view of the ocean. Set high on a hill this modern home offers huge views and an open floor plan. Cathedral ceilings, skylights and wrap...

Secluded Mini Estate in Hamptons

9 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Walk to beach. Enjoy sunsets over the bay in this beautifully designed contemporary central hall Colonial on 1.6 acres. Extremely large 8/ 9 bedrooms, 3.5 baths with state-of-the-art kitchen, formal...

Summer House Hither Woods

5 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

A beautifully located home on an acre of secluded property in the hither woods section of Montauk. A 15 minute walk to your own private ocean beach. The house has 5 bedrooms 3 baths and an outdoor...

Waterfront One Bedroom Condo with Queen Sleeper-Sofa, Pool/Sauna, Tennis, & More

1 bedroom condo in Shelter Island, NY

Lower level unit in Building One facing Fort Pond Bay that sleeps 4 with a queen sized bed and brand-new full sized pull-out sofa. Full size kitchen with dining area and table for 4. Freshly...

Gorgeous light filled home in private waterfront location on Accabonac Bay

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Beautiful, secluded home situated on six waterfront acres with easy access to Accabonac Bay. Paddle boarding and Kayaking literally out the front door. Home recently renovated with large, high-end...

NEWLY renovated stunning home -- THREE weeks Aug. 1--22) (4 BR; 4.5 BA)

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Beautifully restored colonial that oozes charm and clean lines with free flowing lay-out. Just renovated! Close to town (10 minute walk) and close to the water's edge (100 yards). Bellport Ferry to...

New to Market! Hamptons Artisan Estate Close to Sag Harbor and East Hampton

4 bedroom estate in Shelter Island, NY

This 4000 square foot traditional gambrel style home is located on 3.2 quiet acres conveniently situated in Wainscott and close to both Sag Harbor and East Hampton. The house is newly furnished with...

Awesome home, escape the heat in Southampton!

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Enjoy all the Hamptons has to offer in this beautiful, spacious, 4 bedroom/4 bath set on private 1+ acre. We are 1 mile from the bay and 5 miles from the ocean. Don't feel like hitting the beach?...

Beautiful Summer Getaway

8 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Beautiful two level 4,100 sq. ft. home in East Quogue is sure to accommodate all your summer get away needs. Eight bedrooms, four full bathrooms, large open living room area, huge entertainment room...


7 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

This home and property feel like a vacation from the moment you arrive. Just on the edge of the village, A five minute walk to Red Horse Market and a five minute bike-ride to Georgica Beach. This...

Sag Harbor Oasis- 5 beds, heated pool, privacy...ideal for Fall weekends!

5 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Fabulous five bedroom, three and one-half bath, modern, private home. Large heated pool and cabana with Bose speakers surrounded by Trex decking; beyond the pool deck is a tennis court, basketball...

Private Ocean Beach on Treasure Island Drive

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Walk to a private ocean beach from this Decorator Beach House on a private road. Gourmet chef's kitchen and hi end finishes. 4 bedrooms with 2 fireplaces. New Bathrooms. Separate Office. Central...

Charming Cottage in Southampton

3 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Located south of the highway just moments to Main Street and the Atlantic Beaches, this updated and well-kept home is the ideal Hamptons retreat. The bright and freshly painted first floor includes a...

beach house North Fork Vineyards, Farm Stands, Kayaks Sea Side

2 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

This beach bungalow has completely been renovated with a brand new kitchen. It has amazing panoramic views and a large wrap around deck. Kitchen, bathroom and outdoor shower. This home is directly on...

Sag Harbor Waterfront Property with Private Beach

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Situated perfectly for outstanding panoramic water views completely across the Bay is this stylish Contemporary completely renovated to the highest standards. The interior offers 4 bedrooms, 3 and...

Oceanfront Modern Masterpiece

5 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Oceanfront home and a mid-century modern pool house with 8 bedrooms 51/2 bathrooms, a swimming pool, Canadian wood hot tub, steam and dry saunas, 12 zone sound system, large oceanfront deck and...

New Listing: Fabulous French Styled Chateau, Mediterranean Inspired Home

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Mill Path Chateau New Listing: Fabulous French Styled Chateau, Mediterranean Inspired Home 4BR/3.5BA w/ Heated Gunite Pool, Elevator, Screened in Porch and Gourmet Kitchen Be transported to Italy in...
VRBO.com logo

goodideazs, LLC is not affiliated with the authors of this post nor is it responsible for its content, the accuracy and authenticity of which should be independently verified.

About| Advertise| Terms| Privacy| Contact A Greater Town

Copyright © 2007-2018 goodideazs, LLC. All rights reserved.