6BR House Vacation Rental in Shelter Island, New York

Vacation Rentals

Updated on Dec 7, 2017

Escape, Forget, Recharge To This Gorgeous Ultra-Private Compound

Located in: Shelter Island
A spectacular pastoral setting, this historic compound features a country manor home and custom built guest house on 8 acres. The main residence has been beautifully restored with architectural details intact but with all the most up-to-date amenities. This gracious home has a relaxed country décor with a large living room with wood-burning fireplace and is flanked by a delightful sunroom overlooking a meadow. The library is flanked by another screened sunroom overlooking the lawn and garden. The formal dining room with French doors leads to a private stone terrace which is another outdoor dining space, perfect for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The generous eat-in kitchen is outfitted with top of-the-line appliances (Sub-Zero and Viking stove) and two dishwashers. If you’d rather rest and relax and have someone else command the kitchen, might we recommend a visit from Kyle’s Catering. There are 3 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, including an en suite Master with attached private office. Each exquisite marble bath features a beautiful antique commode.

The Carriage house is flooded with light and casual chic decor. There are 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and open living and dining space with French doors leading to a terrace overlooking the heated pool and views of the vast land reserve beyond. Ultra-private and serene, the park-like grounds are filled with native trees, plantings and flowering plants. Simply divine.

This property is offered with a choice of the Main House alone or the Main House + Carriage House. The house is available on a year-round basis or for the summer period; the minimum rental period is one month.

Main House only:
MD-LD: $115K
June: $35K
July: $45K
August: $50K,
July 1 to LD: $90K

Main House and carriage house:
MD-LD: $150K
June: $40K
August: $55K
July 1 to LD: $110K
Get the full listing »

More Vacation Rentals Near Shelter Island,

VRBO.com logo

Majestic Southampton Waterfront

7 bedroom estate in Shelter Island, NY

This is extravagant living at its best. Picture yourself enjoying expansive water views and majestic sunsets. The park like setting lends itself to an idyllic outdoor paradise. This home has 7 huge...

Ocean Beach 4 bedroom –Newly Renovated

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Experience Peaceful Living in a Beautiful Hampton Home on a barrier island, off of Dune road with convenient access to the Sandy White Ocean Beach. This well maintained 4-bedroom, 2+ bathroom house...

Relax in this Spacious, Light-Filled Vacation Home with Pool in Silver Beach

3 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

You will enjoy this family-friendly, spacious, and light-filled beach home featuring a mix of coastal and mid century interior design, located in coveted Silver Beach, a quiet, safe, and charming...

Perfect Family Retreat With Ocean Views, Heated Pool, And Private Beach Access!

5 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

*** EH Rental Registration number: 18-1,030 *** ***Calendar and availability for Summer 2019 will not be available until Fall 2018. If you are interested, please send me an e-mail and I will get...

Montauk Vacation Condo by the Sea

2 bedroom condo in Shelter Island, NY

The condominium is located in a waterfront resort overlooking the tranquil Block Island Sound. The resort is in the desirable Soundview Estates between Culloden shores and Montauk Harbor. The resort...

Beautiful Montauk Ocean View Beach Cottage

3 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

East Hampton Rental Registry number 18-1392 Our gorgeous Montauk beach house--called the "dream beach house" on Mr.Porter's Instagram--is a spacious 3 bedroom house on the coveted Old Montauk...

Beach Front, Pool, Tennis, Spa, Pet Friendly

5 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

July 1-31 $125,000 August 1-25 $220,000 Rare offering of a beach front Hampton home with pool, spa and tennis. Located in one of the most desirable neighborhoods in the world on the most beautiful...

Reserve the now for 2018, June and August still available + holidays

8 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

This "south of the highway" estate is located in Village of Sagaponack, the jewel in the crown of the Hamptons. Open farm fields, beautiful estates and the best of the Atlantic Ocean beaches. We were...

Classic Hamptons Getaway

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Stunning water views from almost every room. Sit on the dock, swim in the pool or stroll to Bridgehampton ocean beaches. Enjoy fabulous sunsets every night from this Mecox bayfront home. Featuring...

Luxury Home Steps From Beach And Short Bike Ride To Vineyards

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Nestled in the tranquil enclave of Nassau Point, this elegant and well-appointed home is situated only a short walk to a beautiful and private powder beach. A second larger beach is a 10 minute walk,...

Welcome to The Hampton Finest Resort

1 bedroom hotel in Shelter Island, NY

Twin Beds, and Full Sofa Bed *3rd Guest subject to Extra charge Upon arrival Fresh plate of Seasonal Fresh Fruit Chocolate Bottled Water During Your Stay Freshly baked Muffins and Croissants...

Bridgehampton Contemporary Designer Decorated + COMPLIMENTARY POOL HEATING!

3 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

This home is modern with clean lines, tastefully designer decorated with contemporary new furnishings and fully renovated kitchens and baths. You wont find any 1990's formica kitchen or bathrooms...

Single Bedroom for July and August in East Hampton ~ Shared Space

2 bedroom cottage in Shelter Island, NY

The house is in Springs, East Hampton, the historic district where the abstract painters made their home. The shared space accommodation is one bedroom upstairs in this home. For an additional...

Quiet, Upscale Escape by the Beach

3 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Our home is on a quiet, tree-lined street, less than a mile from a serene pebble beach, with crystal clear water and breath-taking sunsets. Quaint East Marion is the ideal spot to explore the North...

Sagaponack Sanctuary

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Wonderful 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home in a tony section of Sagaponack. Features include large eat-in kitchen, living room with fireplace, bedroom on the first floor, plus a large bonus room with...

New Listing: Professionally Decorated Estate, Luxe Furnishings & Vast Yard w/ Heated Pool & Tennis

5 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Step inside Noyac Retreat, a beautifully, recently renovated three-story home, set back from the road on a well-manicured 2-acre estate. The property s soaring ceilings and professionally decorated...

East Hampton Escape located one mile from East Hampton town

4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Fabulously interior design home, four bedrooms, three and 1/2 baths, beautifully landscaped acre and heated pool. One acre property. Two Master suites, upstairs and downstairs. Powder room...


4 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION- close to everything, 5 minutes drive to East Hampton Village where all the restaurants and grocery shops and shopping are! Something unique to the neighborhood is a...

Stunning Waterfront Estate House with 180 degree sea views on 7 private acres

5 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

This stunning waterfront Estate House is a quiet paradise nestled in 7 private acres of nature on the pristine Menantic Peninsula. Enjoy strolls along the water’s edge or bask in the sun on the...


6 bedroom house in Shelter Island, NY

Newly gut-renovated by acclaimed HGTV designer this 3,000sf, 6 bedroom 6 bath leaves no stone unturned. All top of the line appliances “Subzero, Viking, etc”. Smart TVs throughout, heated bathroom...
VRBO.com logo

goodideazs, LLC is not affiliated with the authors of this post nor is it responsible for its content, the accuracy and authenticity of which should be independently verified.

About| Advertise| Terms| Privacy| Contact A Greater Town

Copyright © 2007-2018 goodideazs, LLC. All rights reserved.