5BR Cottage Vacation Rental in Interlaken, New York #2871978 | AGreaterTown

5BR Cottage Vacation Rental in Interlaken, New York

Vacation Rentals

Updated on Apr 11, 2019

The Sheldrake House: Timeless Luxury

Located in: Interlaken
Somewhere between perfectly colonial, and timeless and chic - you'll find this beautiful Italianate Finger Lakes estate settled on the west side of Cayuga Lake. Centrally located between Seneca Falls and Ithaca you'll find yourself with an abundance of Finger Lakes fun right at your fingertips!

Sheldrake House, built in 1850, is situated on 2 acres with sweeping views of Cayuga Lake and includes 200 feet of beautiful lakefront. It is nestled between two stunning examples of 19th Century American Architecture in a neighborhood distinguished by large parcels and extensive waterfront holdings, leading to a peaceful and private lakeside experience.

As you pull into the estate, imagine enjoying a cool drink on the wrap around veranda or under the portico where the carriages used to stop. When you are ready to enter, choose between the side entrance to the Library or the front entrance to the Front Hall with its grand staircase.

A formal living room with spectacular lake view is just through the doorway. Traveling further into the first floor you'll find the dining area; offering an understated table below a gleaming Waterford chandelier. The extended table makes mealtime easy and fun when you're with family and friends. Just off the dining area is a second living area with comfortable sofa and another large dining table. Borrow a book off the shelves from the library while you're here and escape into a novel world.

Down the hall, discover the Italian style kitchen with beautiful cabinetry and counter tops. This "Cook's Kitchen" boasts stunning architectural design, and bursts at the seams with all of your favorite cooking and baking ware. Stop at the Ithaca Farmers Market and bring back fresh, brightly colored produce and add a Finger Lakes touch to mealtime.

Located off the kitchen is a breakfast area with garden view where you can mingle with everyone busily working in the kitchen. In the back hall is a generous pantry, second refrigerator, and a half bath with shower.

The second floor offers four of the five bedrooms and two full baths. Each bedroom is designed with floor to ceiling windows offering panoramic garden or lake views. The third floor tower is a quaint bedroom for one with the best views in the house. Consider yourself lucky if you've been able to scoop up this space during your getaway.

Outdoor entertainment and relaxing is easy at Sheldrake House. Whether you're spending time on the new patio off the kitchen, enjoying the shade under the portico, or sitting on the veranda soaking up the views of Cayuga Lake, there is not a space at this home that won't capture your heart and create a fond memory!

The lakefront of this colonial home is located just across the lightly traveled road. A cozy boat house offers a second floor with sheltered seating for 10, a refrigerator, and a raised view over the waterfront. The first floor has storage for chairs and lake toys, and a holds a canoe and two kayaks for use while staying at the House.

Each day at Sheldrake House will be an adventure: whether you're running and playing in the yard, spending time in the cool waters of Cayuga Lake, or exploring the area around you. Visitors will find places like Taughannock Falls, Buttermilk Falls, the Cayuga Lake Creamery and Sheldrake Point Winery the perfect Finger Lakes treat! Call and make your reservation today!

For larger families, book the Sheldrake Cottage located next door in addition to the Sheldrake House.
Get the full listing »

More Vacation Rentals Near Interlaken,

VRBO.com logo

Enjoy Sunsets, Relax At The Pool and Visit Wineries At This Quiet Lakefront Home

5 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

Enjoy your vacation in our updated home on a paved quiet dead-end road. A chef's kitchen awaits you with large island for gathering with views into the open living room and dining room area where you...

Anthony's Big House at Seneca Lake, NY

7 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

This special home was built during the depression by our grandfather K.G. Anthony. Many of the materials used in the construction were hand-picked by K.G. and his attention to detail is evident...

Hidden Gem - Stunning Setting on the East Shore of Cayuga Lake!

2 bedroom cottage in Interlaken, NY

Welcome to Alilys-on-Cayuga! Our quaint 1930’s cottage will make for a most memorable vacation. Relax and enjoy one of the most breathtaking views of Cayuga Lake. Spend the day lounging on our...

Spacious 5 Bedroom Lakeside Retreat in the Heart of Wine Country

5 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

This outstanding property easily accommodates 10 people in comfort with 4 King Bedrooms (Master has ensuite bathroom) and 2 twin beds in the 5th Bedroom. The kitchen is large and has all the amenities...

Rustic Retreat on Seneca Lake Wine Trail - Romantic, Family and Pet Friendly

3 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

Rustic log cottage located on a private road right off the Seneca Lake Wine Trail. The secluded nature of the property offers the safe exploration of woods, streams, and the lakeshore for kids, dogs...

Seneca Lake Home Finger Lakes Wineries Galore 4 BED 4 BATH

4 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

Get away from it all and enjoy the fruits of scenic Central New York! So much to do in the heart of the Finger Lakes Region from the Waterloo Outlets to Watkins Glen! Drive to wineries, breweries,...

Classic Cottage - Minutes from 2 wine trails. Kayaks included!

3 bedroom cottage in Interlaken, NY

This property was recently featured on HGTV's, Lake Front Bargain Hunt, Season 6 Episode 11, Settling in on Seneca Lake! Classic Cottage brings together rustic charm, modern tastes, quiet privacy of...

Below the Vineyard: "Ideal Lakeside Retreat"

6 bedroom cottage in Interlaken, NY

This spectacular 6 bedroom house is positioned on the Seneca Lake Wine Trail. Below the Vineyard is located on the eastern banks of Seneca Lake, just below stunning acres of vineyards. This property...

The View at Lodi Point - Level lakefront w/ 2 kayaks! Explore Seneca Lake!

4 bedroom cottage in Interlaken, NY

Spectacular sunsets and level, natural lakefront are just some the features at The View at Lodi Point. Located in the heart of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail and a short drive to Ithaca, Watkins Glen,...

Rustic Log Cabin Retreat, Cayuga Wine Trail, Dogs Welcome, Open Year-round

2 bedroom cabin in Interlaken, NY

Rustic Log Cabin Vacation Rental – Cayuga Lake – Finger Lakes - Cayuga Wine Trail We have a second cabin on the same property - please check out vrbo 763447 if you can't find the dates you need...

A Delightful Cottage Set on the East Shore of Cayuga Lake...

2 bedroom cottage in Interlaken, NY

Charming describes what you will find when you arrive at Charmante-on-Cayuga. A quaint cottage with a large eat-in kitchen, a deck over looking the lake and a private beach. Just twenty steps down a...

Lovely and private victorian farmhouse on beautiful grounds with pool.

10 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

This property boasts ten bedrooms. Six in the main house and four in the carriage house. The house and extensive lawns (for games) are surrounded by tall pines for maximum privacy. It is old, cozy and...

Beautiful country views close to Ithaca in the Finger Lakes region

3 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

Our home is located just outside of Ithaca NY, eight miles from Cornell University. It is a contemporary home built in 2011. It is clean, bright and cheery, filled with natural light. There are three...

Adorable 2BDR Cottage on Seneca Lake near Wineries

2 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

This cottage sits on a huge lawn across the street from the lake, and features 2 bedrooms, a living room, small kitchen, and gorgeous screened in porch with lake view. It also includes a private dock...

10 minutes to Watkins Glen & by local attractions!

1 bedroom studio in Interlaken, NY

Enjoy this private and unique lodging experience over looking Seneca Lake. The rental is situated in the heart of the region's most popular wineries, breweries and attractions. Come stay with Us and...

Carriage House in heart of FLX Wine-Country

4 bedroom house in Interlaken, NY

Come stay in a reconstructed 1887 carriage house set on 16 private acres, yet right next to Finger Lakes National Forest land and close to so much! Between both wine trails, with amazing places to...

lake view room in Estate on wine trail! Just 10 minutes to Watkins Glen.

1 bedroom estate in Interlaken, NY

We welcome you to experience the stay to remember! The stunning mansion is nestled on 23 acres offering awe-inspiring views of Seneca Lake. From your private room or our grounds, you can watch the...

Sheldrake Cottage: 1 BR, 1 BA Cottage in Interlaken, Sleeps 4

1 bedroom cottage in Interlaken, NY

Centrally located between Seneca Falls and Ithaca you'll find yourself with an abundance of Finger Lakes fun right at your fingertips when you choose to stay at Sheldrake Cottage. Acting as overflow...

Bufflehead Bungalow: "Family Fun!"

2 bedroom cottage in Interlaken, NY

Centrally located between the gorges of Ithaca and the canal side of Seneca Falls, you’ll find this cozy bungalow nestled in a wooded clearing. Your time to relax, and unwind has arrived! Enter...

Beautiful waterfront cottage on Cayuga Lake

3 bedroom cabin in Interlaken, NY

This quaint waterfront cottage features a cozy sitting area with a fireplace and an eat-in-kitchen. On the first floor you'll find a full bathroom, and bedroom with a queen bed as well as a futon in...
VRBO.com logo

goodideazs, LLC is not affiliated with the authors of this post nor is it responsible for its content, the accuracy and authenticity of which should be independently verified.

About| Advertise| Terms| Privacy| Contact A Greater Town

Copyright © 2007-2018 goodideazs, LLC. All rights reserved.