3BR Cottage Vacation Rental in Honeoye, New York

Vacation Rentals

Updated on Jul 16, 2020

Charming, Family-friendly Cottage In Park-like, Lakefront Setting

Located in: Honeoye
If you’re looking for a relaxing getaway on the Finger Lakes, you’ll find it at Buttercup Cottage. This unique property features the elbow room of a park-like setting and offers outstanding privacy, gorgeous views and the charm of a country cottage.

The property includes two cottages that can sleep 8 guests. The main cottage features two bedrooms (one with queen bed, one with a bunk that sleeps 3), kitchen with eat-in area, a living room with cable TV, and a screen porch with panoramic views of the lake.

The guest cottage is ideal for visitors, in-laws or older kids. It includes a king bed and a twin, a bathroom with shower stall, and large screen porch with a picnic table facing the lake. There's also an outdoor shower facing west that’s ideal for rinsing off in the sun after a dip in the lake.

The yard is unusually large for a lake property, occupying .8 acre of grass for you to play Whiffle ball or touch football, or just lounge in the sun.

To the south of the main house, overlooking the lake, is a gazebo with a picnic table for dinners looking at the lake as the sun sets.

The waterfront, accessible by stairs, features an L-shaped dock and a boat house with canoe.

Buttercup Cottage is located on the west side of Honeoye Lake, about a mile south of the town of Honeoye. This quiet location, surrounded by friendly, quiet, summer-long neighbors, is an ideal setting for a relaxing vacation.

Things to do include some of the best walleye and bass fishing in NY State, visiting local wineries, or enjoying the breathtaking view from Harriet Hollister State Park, at the south end of the lake.

For boaters, Honeoye Lake has a state boat launch and the clean, quiet lake is idea for all kinds of water sports.

Please note: During the peak season from mid-June through early September, Buttercup Cottage has a 7-night minimum. During peak season, check in is on Saturdays at 3 p.m., and check out is on Saturdays at 11 a.m.
Get the full listing »

More Vacation Rentals Near Honeoye,

VRBO.com logo

Gorgeous Waterfront Cottage On The Finger Lakes

2 bedroom cottage in Honeoye, NY

The Finger Lake Area is a well kept secret with many hidden treasure spots to explore. It has something for everyone to find and enjoy. This beautiful year round lake house is within minutes of...

Lakefront, family friendly home with beautiful lake frontage; unobstructed views

3 bedroom house in Honeoye, NY

This home features 2 main floor bedrooms one with a queen and one with a full size bed. There is also loft space with 4 single beds. Also included is a sleep sofa and futon. There are 1.5 baths and...

Wine Country Getaway--Jim's South Bristol Guest House

3 bedroom cabin in Honeoye, NY

Need a gift? Gift certificates are available. Summer is coming! Now is the time to reserve. Book your trip now! Come to the Finger Lakes and wander the Hills in search of wineries and a whole...

Nature Lovers Getaway Nestled In The Hills Of The Finger Lakes Region..

1 bedroom cottage in Honeoye, NY

Sit back and relax during your stay while enjoying the sounds of our waterfall from the hot tub. Our home boasts 1 bedrooms featuring plush queen size bed, fully stocked kitchen, wireless internet,...

Beautiful sunsets on the lake, spectacular views from prime north-east location

3 bedroom house in Honeoye, NY

----------------- ADVISORY: A fraudster has been posting this property on CraigsList. The only legitimate posting for this site is on VRBO and its affiliates (HomeAway, Expedia, Travelocity, etc)....

Conesus Lake Cottage Rental, Sleeps 6

2 bedroom cottage in Honeoye, NY

The house is located off East Lake Road at the south end of Conesus Lake. It’s not directly on the lake but a short walk will get you to our private dock. The house is a 900 sq ft ranch with 2...

Conesus Lake Paradise: "Tranquil and stunning lake house"

3 bedroom cottage in Honeoye, NY

The beautiful three-bedroom Conesus Lake Paradise home is just as tranquil and stunning as the lake that laps right up to it. This recently upgraded lake home has all of the contemporary conveniences...

Rest and relax- great view of Hemlock hills and surrounding area

2 bedroom apartment in Honeoye, NY

Finished apartment with deck above Christmas Tree Storage building. Separate entrance with one set of stairs. Country setting with superb views, ponds, wooded areas and excellent wildlife viewing....

South East Side Serenity - Pet friendly waterfront cottage near Letchworth

3 bedroom cottage in Honeoye, NY

South East Side Serenity offers stunning lake views and comfortable accommodations for guests of all ages to enjoy the lake. Located towards the southern end of Conesus Lake, this alluring cottage...

The Mission Small Group

2 bedroom castle in Honeoye, NY

Welcome to St. Michael's Mission, circa 1925. Come, relax on 50 sprawling & secluded acres. Adjoining 150 acre nature conserve with splendid hiking leads to Hemlock Lake, a privatized & undeveloped...

Stoney Beach Cottage on Conesus Lake - Newly Renovated 2017

4 bedroom cottage in Honeoye, NY

Enjoy your vacation relaxing in this fully remodeled 4 bedroom, 2 bath cottage with 2 tiered deck. Seventy-five feet of beach front makes water perfect for swimming or children playing. 2 Kayaks...

Remodeled House...Steps away from Honeoye Lake

3 bedroom house in Honeoye, NY

Come relax and enjoy all that Honeoye Lake and the surrounding Finger Lakes have to offer at this newly remodeled 1,300 sq. ft. year-round home. The main level has an open floor plan featuring a...

Heron Cove Sanctuary - Peace, Privacy & Beauty!

2 bedroom cottage in Honeoye, NY

Commanding a private cove, our upgraded cottage is tucked over a bridge at the end of the road -- the only house in 500' of hillside lake front, next to a waterfall and two running streams. Peaceful....

Private 3Bd3.5Ba w/Gorg Views of Canandaigua Lake! <COVID-19 Book w/Confidence>

3 bedroom house in Honeoye, NY

<COVID-19 Update: We have extended our flexible cancellation policy and will refund 100% of your deposit if you decide to cancel for reasons related to COVID> Overview: This house is located on the...

Waterfront House on Honeoye Lake

5 bedroom house in Honeoye, NY

Lake front Property on Honeoye Lake. It's a large waterfront property. There is a large deck overlooking the waterfront. The property has 50 feet of waterfront, and a dock and a boat hoist. The...


1 bedroom cabin in Honeoye, NY

I am pleased to add "Maxwell's Mountain Cabin" to my VRBO/HOMEAWAY portfolio. This cabin is one of the best deals in the Finger Lakes! VERY reasonably priced, awesome views, a huge deck area, all...

Lake Front Luxury!!!

3 bedroom house in Honeoye, NY

Very unique property on Lake Honeoye. 107 feet of waterfront with dock and boat lift as well as a fine pebble beach area. Lakehouse fully renovated in 2016 to include a gourmet kitchen as well as an...

Relax, Enjoy and Rest away

4 bedroom cottage in Honeoye, NY

Charming and home feel property that sits on the shores of Conesus Lake. Plenty of space for kids and adults to play games like volleyball, bocce ball, can jam, fris bee, soccer, bad minton or just...

Cozy Walkout Waterfront Cottage on Honeoye Lake!

2 bedroom house in Honeoye, NY

Our cozy cottage is a two bedroom, one bath, home. Recently renovated and upgraded with gas range/oven, washer/dryer onsite, on-demand hot water tank, and beautiful walk out deck that spans the width...

Honeoye Haven, A place you'll come back to

3 bedroom house in Honeoye, NY

Honeoye Haven. Newly remodeled cottage that feels like you're in the Florida Keys. Drive up, walk in and walk right to the water. No stairs at all. Just a perfect ranch to enjoy with loved ones....
VRBO.com logo

goodideazs, LLC is not affiliated with the authors of this post nor is it responsible for its content, the accuracy and authenticity of which should be independently verified.

About| Advertise| Terms| Privacy| Contact A Greater Town

Copyright © 2007-2018 goodideazs, LLC. All rights reserved.